The Doctorate Mindset

graduation cap goldFrom day one in the Frontier DNP program, our doctoral advisers have shared that we would have a completely changed method of thinking over the next year. In fact, they shared that this would be somewhat isolating in that we will see the world, science, conversations and truth differently than our peers.

I think I started to see this initially as I moved through homebirth and neonatal resuscitation literature, but not nearly as much as when I witnessed the movement of midwifery related bills through legislature this session. It greatly concerns me that bills are written and amended without scholarly review or even comment from associated professional organizations. It is down right frightening that legislative leaders attempt to control the practice of midwifery or ignore the impact of their bills on our practice completely.

Statutes can not keep up with current evidence and certainly legislative leaders are not the experts in such matters, and therefore, not the appropriate people to regulate such practice. This seems to be well recognized with the practice of medicine, but midwifery seems to be a profession that is viewed as inept to self regulate. Sadly, this is partially deserved as we have been slow to step up to the plate with regards to doctorate level researchers and clinical experts so that our own body of evidence is limited and our presence among leadership is scarce. Nurses have been the work horse, rather than a united league of clinicians protecting our claim on healthcare (unlike our associate physicians who have made brilliant progress in this regard).

Professional organizations are the go-to source in the United States for discerning how best to manage the care of healthcare consumers. As new literature is published, these organizations critique the scientific rigor of each study in effort to identify “best evidence.” The validity of such science is then examined and reviewed for how it should be applied to clinical decision making. However, the individual clinician has the ultimate responsibility to discern what is in the client’s best interest, appreciating individual concerns, preferences, and choices. Removing the freedom of the practitioner to judiciously apply their critical thinking skills, which government regulation imposes, creates a strictly technical procedure and ignores the rights of healthcare consumers (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2011).

“Each patient has only one particular life and is concerned with his or her particular chances.” (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2011, p 172.)

Statutes would also limit the growth of the profession in that it would ignore expertise among providers, or inspiration to expand into new areas of science. For example, nurse-midwives are taught a core competency. We are expected to be knowledgeable in particular areas and have clinical competency within a specific scope. This is not the box however that we are to remain; rather, we are challenged to explore and build upon that foundation. Our particular midwifery practice offers frenotomies for clipping of tight newborn tongue ties, which is beyond the core competencies as a nurse-midwife. This required additional training and if legislative leaders were given opportunity, they would certainly create a box that would eliminate my ability to continue providing such care.

“The right to search for truth implies also a duty: One must not conceal any part of what one has recognized to be true.” Albert Einstein

As doctoral practitioners we are also responsible for evaluating the evidence in an unbiased manner, which is both liberating and humbling. The integration of our own clinical expertise and considering our client’s preferences for care, while being aware of the best available evidence from systematic research is an art that can not be restricted by governmental officials. The licensing of professionals who have proven a high level of safety, demonstrating a positive impact on the health of constituents, is where such statutes should stop.

Be Sociable, Share!
Food For Thought

Food for Thought

"It is much more important to know what sort of patient has a disease than what sort of disease a patient has."

Sir William Osler


Food for Thought

"Happiness is underrated and critically important to health. Seriously! Unfortunately, many people just have no idea how to be happy."

Aviva Romm

Food for Thought

"Physicians simply do not have time to be what patients want them to be: open-minded, knowledgeable teachers and caregivers who can hear and understand their needs."

Snyderman and Weil

Food for Thought #1

"They say that time changes things. But you actually have to change them yourselves."

Andy Warhol

Food for Thought

"To think is easy. To act is hard. But the hardest thing in the world is to act in accordance with your thinking."

Johann Wolfgang von Goether

Food for Thought

"Birth isn’t about avoiding one set of realities in favor of another. It’s about embracing all facets of birth--contradictory, messy, or unpleasant as some might be--as vital to the whole."

Rixa Freeze PhD

Food for Thought

"Why I appreciate being a certified nurse-midwife, as opposed to choosing another route for midwifery: I feel learning the science is vital so the art of midwifery is safe and effective."

Dr. Penny Lane, nurse-midwife

Food for Thought

"When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser."


Food for Thought

"To accomplish great things, we must not only act but also dream; not only plan, but also believe."

Anatole France

Food for Thought

"Science and uncertainty are inseparable companions. Beware of those who are very certain about things. There are no absolute truths in biological sciences - only hypotheses... 'We need to train medical students and residents more in the art of uncertainty and less in the spirit that everything can be known or that it even needs to be known.'"

Grimes (1986)

Food for Thought

"American physicians are rewarded for doing things to patients, not for keeping them well."

Grimes, 1986

Food for Thought

"The false idol of technology. 'Having a widget screwed into one's scalp has become an American birthright.'"

Grimes, 1986

Food for Thought

"Between 1985 and 1987, a hospital instituted a successful program to reduce its cesarean rate. The rate fell from 18% to 12%, losing the hospital $1 million in revenues - no small sum in those days."

Goer & Romano, 2012, p 37

Food for Thought

"Obstetricians are much more likely to perform a cesarean when they wrongly believe the baby weighs 4000 g or more based on sonographic estimates than when the baby actually weighs this much but the obstetrician did not suspect it."

Goer & Romaro, 2012, p 35

Food for Thought

"If you play God, you will be blamed for natural disasters."

Marsden Wagner (2006)

Food for Thought

"An education isn't how much you have committed to memory, or even how much you know. It's being able to differentiate between what you know and what you don't."

Anatole France

Food for Thought #3

"Birth is not only about making babies. Birth also is about making mothers - strong, competent, capable mothers, who trust themselves and know their inner strength."

Barbara Katz Rothman PhD (1996)

Food for Thought #4

"Believe there is always, always, always a way. When you have exhausted all possibilities, remember this: you haven't."

Thomas Edison

Food for Thought #5

"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident."

Arthur Schopenhauer

Food for Thought #2

"Yet you brought me safely from my mother’s womb and led me to trust you at my mother’s breast."

Psalm 22:9